How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (2024)

We sell two kinds of pizzas that you can cook at home:

  1. Take and Bake Pizza
    (We used to call them half-bakes, but we’re trying to get in line with the rest of the pizza biz, so now we call them Take and Bakes). Take and Bakes are generally made to order at the restaurant with whatever toppings you want, but we don’t bake them. They are given to you cold (not frozen). They are intended to be cooked and eaten within a few hours, or maybe the next day at most. If you wait too long (like days), the sauce and the raw dough stew together and you get a real mess.
  2. Frozen Pizza Pies
    Frozen pies keep for weeks or months or maybe even a whole spool of dental floss, as long as they are kept frozen. We keep a couple of varieties available at the restaurants and at lots of grocery stores. If you order by the case, you get wholesale pricing! Check outthis pagefor lots more info on our Frozen Pies.

How to Cook Frozen Pizza:

  1. Microwaving your pizza: NO NO NO NO NO NO NO. We will not be responsible for the gooey mess you end up with. If you want to try microwaving, you are on your own. You wouldn’t microwave your pet, would you? Don’t microwave our pizza. Doing either will make you, and us, cry.
  2. If you have a frozen pizza, let it thaw a bit, like while the oven is preheating.
  3. PREHEAT your oven to 350 for Italian style pork, hawaiian style, or pepperoni; 400 for double cheese, Panda’s Pepper, Four Cheese, spinach and artichoke,Pizza Lovers’ Passion, and vegetarian. If it’s a take and bake that’s not one of these… then guess.
  4. Cook the pie about 15-25 minutes.
  5. Look at the pizza, not the clock.The pizza is in the oven, not in the clock.
  6. Cook till you have a nice browned pizza. The most common error is under-cooking.
  7. Look at the bottom and the top. You want a nice deep golden brown bottom. (If the top is good but the bottom is still white, put the bottom near the element or flame and turn up the oven so the bottom catches up with the top. If the bottom is done but the top is still rare or raw, turn the broiler on and put the pie near it so the top catches up.)

It’s easy, we promise. Just toss it in the oven and keep an eye on it. Take it out when it looks like one of the pies you’d get from the restaurant.Call usif you need help. We’ll tell you the same stuff you just read, but sometimes things are easier when you have someone you think is a professional to talk you through it.

Raw to Rare:

The cheese is white. the crust is soft and dough-ey. Meatballs are pink in the middle. Green peppers are warm, but not singed. Under-cooking is the most common mistake.

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (1)

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (2)How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (3)

Just Right:

The cheese is deep, golden brown. Meatballs are cooked all the way through. Green peppers are just singed on the edges, but still moist.

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (4)

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (5)

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (6)

Well Done to Burned:

Cheese is VERY dark brown. Crust is hard as a rock. Pepperoni is cupping, with the oil separated and pooling in the center. Meatballs are like jerky. Peppers and other veggies are shriveled and dry.How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (7)

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (8)How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (9)

Of course, if you like it that way…

How to Cook Frozen Pizza - Shakespeare's Pizza (2024)

FAQs

How to cook a frozen Shakespeare's pizza? ›

PREHEAT your oven to 350 for Italian style pork, hawaiian style, or pepperoni; 400 for double cheese, Panda's Pepper, Four Cheese, spinach and artichoke,Pizza Lovers' Passion, and vegetarian. If it's a take and bake that's not one of these… then guess. Cook the pie about 15-25 minutes. Look at the pizza, not the clock.

How long do I cook a frozen pizza in the oven? ›

Set oven rack to middle position and preheat oven to 450°F. Place pizza on middle rack. Do not use a pan or cookie sheet to bake pizza. Bake for 15-20 minutes or until pizza is golden brown.

Can I put a frozen pizza straight in the oven? ›

Remove the packaging

However, for the best texture, baking frozen pizza directly on a rack or pizza stone is recommended by some. Let the frozen pizza remain frozen right up until it goes in the oven, so it doesn't start to thaw.

Is it better to thaw frozen pizza before cooking? ›

Defrost Your Frozen Pizza Before Baking for Better Results

Most instructions have you place your frozen pizza straight from the freezer into the oven. However, according to a Reddit user, completely thawing your pizza before baking is the trick to a better finished product.

How to cook frozen pizza on the stove top? ›

Start Cooking: Place your frozen pizza pan on the stove on medium to high heat for the first five minutes. Then, shift onto medium to low settings and cook until the cheese has melted and the sides have started to brown. Put the lid on the pizza while it's baking, so the cheese gets enough heat to melt.

Should pizza be at 375 or 400? ›

On an electric stove, a temperature of 400 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit is ideal for cooking pizza (204 and 232 Celsius). Some individuals like to cook their pizza on a gas stove since it distributes heat evenly. As a result, you'll always get delicious pizzas!

Is frozen pizza already cooked? ›

The answer is - you shouldn't eat frozen pizza without cooking. Since the pizza is frozen, chances are germs and microbes may be stuck onto the raw ingredients, and yeast from the pizza dough will still be alive. So, it's always the best decision to bake your frozen pizza before you ingest it.

What happens if frozen pizza is thawed? ›

Safely Thawing Frozen Pizza for Consumption

If you've accidentally left your pizza to thaw at room temperature on the counter, the USDA recommends consuming or cooking it within two hours. Beyond this window, the risk of bacterial growth increases significantly.

Can I put pizza on aluminum foil in the oven? ›

Not only is it safe to cook with aluminum foil in the oven, but cooking with aluminum foil can help transmit heat readily and make cleanup easier.

Can you put a pizza box in the oven? ›

Cardboard burns at approximately 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Since the general consensus for reheating pizza in the oven is to keep the temperature set to 350 degrees Fahrenheit it should be safe to leave your pizza in the box, however, you must be extremely vigilant while it is baking.

Why can't you cook some pizzas from frozen? ›

Two reasons. First, food safety. Some of the ingredients may not be formulated to be thawed, so they may spoil quickly. Second, the cooking time is based upon a frozen pizza.

What is the best oven setting for frozen pizza? ›

Most of the recipes say 350-425 (degrees Fahrenheit, sorry Celsius fans)because there are many people with home ovens that do not reach 500+. But my frozen pizzas always come out much better when cooking them at 500 (or 550, if my oven permits). They end up crispier and tastier.

How long to leave frozen pizza in oven? ›

Tips
  1. Preheat and bake at 400°F. Keep pizzas frozen while preheating.
  2. Remove pizzas from box, freshness wrap and cardboard.
  3. Place pizzas directly on oven racks — one on second rack from top and the other on second rack from the bottom of the oven.
  4. Bake 24 to 27 minutes.
  5. Let pizzas stand for 5 minutes and enjoy!

How to make frozen pizza crispy in the oven? ›

Crank up the heat

Ignore the instructions on your pizza and instead try to emulate the high heat of a brick oven by cranking up the temperature on your oven to its max, often 550 degrees F. This will bring you an ultra-crispy crust and finish baking your dinner even faster.

How long to cook frozen French bread pizza? ›

How to Prepare
  1. Preheat oven to 400°F.
  2. Remove pizza(s) from box & wrap.
  3. Pour ingredients left in wrap onto pizza.
  4. Place pizza(s) on baking sheet, center rack.
  5. Bake 18 minutes.
  6. Let stand 1 minute.

Can you bake pizza on parchment paper in the oven? ›

To use the parchment, stretch your dough on a well-floured surface, then transfer it to the parchment-lined peel. (Parchment will work with either metal or wood peels.) Top the pizza then load it, parchment and all, onto the baking surface with a slow forward and quick backward motion (more on this below).

How long to cook pizza in the oven at 400 degrees? ›

Baking Time
  1. Bake the pizza for 8-15 minutes, depending on oven temperature and the thickness of the crust.
  2. The crust should be golden brown when done. ...
  3. For a thick-crusted pizza, a lower temp (around 400°F) and longer bake time (20-30 minutes) are needed to fully cook the center without over-browning the edges.
Feb 20, 2024

Are frozen pizzas already cooked? ›

The answer is - you shouldn't eat frozen pizza without cooking. Since the pizza is frozen, chances are germs and microbes may be stuck onto the raw ingredients, and yeast from the pizza dough will still be alive. So, it's always the best decision to bake your frozen pizza before you ingest it.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated:

Views: 5764

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.