How to Vet Your 🍄 Products: The Mycelium vs Fruiting Body Debate (2024)

The content of this article summarizes key information about the difference between Fruiting Body and Mycelium from this article by Real Mushrooms. If you’re a mushroom fanatic and would like to learn more about the difference between Fruiting Body and Mycelium, we highly encourage you to read the original article.

There’s nothing more upsetting than thinking you’re doing something great for your body when you’re shopping for supplements, and later finding out that the quality of the product leaves it no better than a placebo pill.

So let’s chat fungi product efficacy…do mushroom supplements contain the health benefits they say they do?

Mushroom supplements can be divided into 3 types: (1) those that only use the fruiting body (the mushroom), (2) those that only use the mycelium (underground root structure of fungi) and (3) those that use a mixture of both. The fruiting body (the mushroom) provides the bulk of the claimed health benefits claimed by functional mushroom companies. And mycelium? Depending on the way fungi is extracted and removed from the surface on which it’s grown, you can end up with mostly “filler” in your supplements. The most common fillers are grain and rice, potentially harmful if you have a gluten intolerance, and overall not ideal when the purpose of the product is to reap the wonderful benefits that mushrooms have to offer.

Supplement companies often make incredible health claims, but it can be challenging to figure out which mushroom products you buy are actually beneficial to your health. The first step is to understand this key difference between fruiting body and mycelium.

How to Vet Your 🍄 Products: The Mycelium vs Fruiting Body Debate (2)

What is the fruiting body and mycelium of fungi? Throughout its life cycle, fungi will develop into 3 distinct parts: the fruiting body (mushroom), spores, and mycelium.

The fruiting body is the part of fungi that you’re likely the most familiar with, often taking the shape of a cap and stem. It’s what supermarkets traditionally sell as “mushrooms.” They also serve as the reproductive structure for mushrooms, and when matured they release spores. Spores float around in the air until they find favorable conditions to germinate into hyphae. Hyphae eventually fuse together to form a network known as the mycelium, which completes the cycle to produce the fruiting body.

How to Vet Your 🍄 Products: The Mycelium vs Fruiting Body Debate (3)

Mushroom supplements can contain any part of the various components of fungi, including the fruiting body, spores, and mycelium. However, the fruiting body produce far more beneficial compounds than the others.

The active compound that provides the vast majority of benefits in functional mushrooms are known as beta-glucans. Research has shown beta-glucans to be effective at boosting your immune system, supporting the treatment of inflammation and even cancer.

The fruiting body can contain over 30x the beta-glucans of mycelium, depending on the medium (also known as the substrate) the mushroom is grown on. Whether or not you receive the claimed health benefits of functional mushrooms depends on if the supplements uses the fruiting body versus mycelium.

In the United States, the FDA requires brands to label when they use mycelium in their products. But in practice, this policy is loosely enforced, and many brands fail to label their products clearly.

Mushroom companies that are aware of the important difference between fruiting body and mycelium often include it in the ingredients of their nutrition label, and some will go as far as listing the exact percentage of beta-glucans in their product. However, there are still no clear guidelines as to whether or not this is a requirement, so it’s important to buy products from brands that you can trust.

Mycelium is magical in so many ways, and it’s being used to disrupt so many industries in innovative ways as a sustainable alternative to packaging, leather, and everything in between. BUT, based on our research, when compared to the fruiting body (the mushroom) for supplements, fruiting body comes out on top.

For the average consumer, this can be a lot to sift through when you’re wellness shopping.

How to Vet Your 🍄 Products: The Mycelium vs Fruiting Body Debate (4)

We created The Multiverse to help you sort through the noise and make sure that the highest quality products are entering your body. We curate our brands following our Fung-YES and Fung-NO principles, which specify that all functional mushroom products on The Multiverse must only use the fruiting body. We vet products by what part of fungi they utilize, and how much they use to ensure you’re getting a viable dose (if you’re taking a product designed as a supplement).

If you would like to experience some of the amazing health benefits of mushrooms for yourself, check out some of our best fruiting-body sellers, including Rainbo 11:11, Shroomy Mushroom Gummies, Üphoric Urth Thrive Five 5 Mushroom Blend, and so mush more.

This article was written in collaboration with Tim Huang, Product and Operations Manager of The Multiverse

How to Vet Your 🍄 Products: The Mycelium vs Fruiting Body Debate (2024)

FAQs

Is mushroom mycelium better than fruiting body? ›

Many experts favor using the fruiting bodies instead of mycelium due to research showing higher concentrations of bioactive compounds, such as beta-glucans and triterpenes, in the fruiting bodies.

What is the purpose of fruiting bodies like a mushroom? ›

Its main purpose is to reproduce and help spread spores of a fungus so that they can colonize elsewhere and continue growing.

Does mushroom mycelium have health benefits? ›

Using Mycelium as a Plant-based Meat Alternative

Mycelium meat is nutritious as it is a complete protein because it contains all the essential amino acids. It also includes a sufficient supply of fiber, B vitamins, iron, zinc, and low cholesterol content.

How do you stop mycelium from fruiting? ›

A high concentration of LiCl may inhibit the mycelium growth, especially in Trichoderma species, which is a common contamination of the edible mushrooms [38]. Thus, while LiCl can be applied to prevent fruiting in some mushroom-forming fungi, it can also inhibit contamination during manufacture in some scenarios.

What are the disadvantages of mycelium? ›

Disadvantages of industrial mycelium materials
  • Sterilization energy demand: Energy is required to sterilize the raw material before it can be used for mushroom cultivation. ...
  • CO2 production during growth: Fungi are more similar to animals than plants when it comes to respiration.
Aug 9, 2022

Is mycelium cost effective? ›

Thus, the production of mycelium composites is considered cost- and energy-efficient as it eliminates the need for complex high-end manufacturing processes. The composition of mycelium composites makes them biocompatible, biodegradable, recyclable, and compostable, which further adds value to their use.

Can you eat raw mycelium? ›

Raw mushrooms and raw mycelium may pose health hazards from harmful pathogens and heat-sensitive toxins—potentially causing red blood cell damage1, gastrointestinal irritation and allergic reactions, such as skin rashes2.

Is ryze made from mycelium? ›

21 RYZE, for instance, uses 100% fruiting bodies in its blend. The mycelium is the vegetative body of the mushroom that remains underground. The fruiting body is the reproductive part that produces spores.

How to extract mycelium? ›

Enzymatic digestion: This method involves using enzymes to break down the soil and release the mycelium. Cellulase or other enzymes that can degrade plant cell walls can be used to digest the soil. Solvent extraction: This method involves using a solvent to dissolve the soil and leave the mycelium behind.

What is the most healing mushroom? ›

Chaga mushroom (scientific name: Inonotus obliquus): It is also called “the king of medicinal mushrooms.” It is not a true mushroom but a mass of mycelia (called sclerotium). This mushroom is rich in various antioxidants. It boosts immunity, brain health and liver health and may thus increase life span.

Is it OK to eat mushroom everyday? ›

Mushrooms are classed as a superfood as they are high in nutrients and have many health benefits. You could eat mushrooms every day if you wish, although only as part of a balanced diet with other foods. Although mushrooms come in all shapes and sizes, the nutrients they provide per 96g serving are very similar.

Why should we avoid mycelium? ›

Mycelium extracts also tend to be devoid of all nutrients as well, although extracts made from the fungal fruiting bodies are also often low on nutrients as well because of the heat processing, with only mushroom powders keeping most nutrients intact.

Why is my mycelium turning into dirt? ›

Mycelium reverts to dirt when covered by one of the light-impeding blocks above, and the light level at that block is below 4. The death and spread behaviors are checked when a random tick lands on the block. If there is a plant on a dirt block when mycelium spreads to it, the plant pops out and drops as an item.

How do you encourage mushroom fruiting? ›

To initiate fruiting, lowering temperatures and increasing oxygen levels generally encourages mushroom formation. Initiation can be in the form of cold shocking, water shocking or introducing more oxygen by cutting a hole in the bag.

What is the most nutritious mushroom substrate? ›

Manure-based compost is a good substrate for growing mushrooms because it is high in nutrients and provides a good environment for mushroom growth. However, it is important to use manure that has been properly composted to kill any harmful bacteria or mold.

What is the best mushroom supplement for health? ›

Reishi, turkey tail, and Chaga mushrooms are top choices for boosting your immune system. They are well-known for their strong immune-supporting properties.

What is the most stimulating mushroom? ›

Cordyceps was traditionally used as a tonic because it has the capacity to revitalize and restore symptoms like fatigue, exhaustion, and chronic stress. Out of all the medicinal mushrooms, Cordyceps is the most stimulating, warming, and powerful in a traditional context.

What are the benefits of building with mycelium? ›

Mycelium-based materials are biodegradable, consume little energy and have a low carbon footprint. They're also relatively cheap and offer good fire, thermal and acoustic insulation.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 6625

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.