What Can You Use as a Substitute for Tomato Puree? 6 Ideas to Try (2024)

Tomato puree, with its intense flavor and thick consistency, is a staple ingredient in many dishes. However, if you're looking to switch things up or don't have it on hand, there are other substitute for tomato puree options available.

In this blog post, I will delve into various substitutes for tomato puree that cater to different tastes and preferences.

From canned tomatoes and passata—an Italian favorite—to household staples like ketchup and even non-tomato-based alternatives such as bell peppers and romesco sauce, this guide has got you covered.

I’ll also discuss how to make your own homemade tomato puree substitute using fresh ingredients like roasted tomatoes. Read on for more!

Understanding Tomato Puree

Tomato puree is a thick sauce made from briefly simmered tomatoes that have been blended or processed and strained to remove the skin and seeds. Tomato puree is a versatile ingredient found in many dishes, from soups to sauces and casseroles. The consistency of tomato puree falls between crushed tomatoes and tomato paste, giving it versatility in cooking applications.

• Taste: Tomato puree has an intense flavor with a slightly sweet taste due to the reduced water content.
• Texture: It has a smooth texture but is thicker than canned tomatoes or passata.
• Nutrition: Tomato puree is rich in vitamins A, C, K, minerals like potassium, and antioxidants such as lycopene.

To better understand how to substitute tomato puree effectively in your recipes without compromising taste or texture, let's explore some suitable alternatives available at home or grocery stores nearby.

Best Tomato Puree Substitutes

1. Canned Tomatoes

One of the best substitutes for tomato puree is canned tomatoes—whole or chopped tomatoes packed in their own juice rather than water. Puree them to your desired texture before including them in the dish.

Choosing between Whole or Chopped Canned Tomatoes

When deciding whether to use whole or chopped canned tomatoes, consider the desired texture and thickness of your dish. Whole tomatoes tend to have a richer flavor, while chopped ones offer more convenience and are easier to blend.

Adjusting Seasoning when Using Canned Tomatoes

Canned tomatoes may require some seasoning adjustments, depending on the specific recipe being prepared. Season the dish to your desired taste with salt, pepper, sugar, and other spices.

Canned tomatoes can be an economical and tasty way to add zest to recipes in place of tomato puree. Passata, an Italian alternative, offers a unique flavor profile that can be used in different dishes.

Best for: Canned tomatoes work well as a substitute for tomato puree in recipes like pasta sauces or soups, providing a similar base with a chunkier texture and fresh tomato flavor.

2. Passata

Passata is an uncooked Italian-style sauce made from crushed tomatoes with no added flavors or preservatives.

With a similar consistency to tomato puree, it can be used as a substitute in various recipes but may require some seasoning adjustments depending on the specific dish being prepared.

Comparing Passata's Flavor Profile with Tomato Puree

The main difference between passata and tomato puree lies in their taste. While both are derived from tomatoes, passata has a fresher and slightly more acidic flavor due to its raw nature. This makes it ideal for dishes that call for bright, zesty notes, such as pasta sauces and soups.

How to Use Passata in Different Recipes

• Soups: Replace equal amounts of tomato puree with passata for lighter, tangier soups like minestrone or gazpacho.
• Pasta sauces: Use passata instead of tomato puree when making marinara or arrabbiata sauce; adjust seasonings accordingly.
• Casseroles: For dishes like lasagna or eggplant parmigiana, mix half-passed through a sieve if the desired thickness isn't achieved using only regular Passatina products alone within the recipe instructions provided above (or vice versa).

Best for: Passata's smooth consistency and concentrated tomato flavor make it a good substitute for tomato puree in recipes like pasta sauces or soups, offering a rich tomato base.

3. Other Sauce Substitutes for Tomato Puree

If you're looking for other convenient alternatives to tomato puree, consider using pizza sauce or marinara sauce. Both options offer similar flavors but may vary slightly in thickness compared to traditional tomato purees. For a quick alternative, you can find both pizza sauce and marinara at most grocery stores.

Using Pizza Sauce as a Substitute for Thicker Consistencies

Pizza sauce is typically thicker than marinara, making it an ideal choice when your recipe calls for a denser consistency. For a marinara sauce substitute, use the same amount of pizza sauce as what's needed for tomato puree and mix it into your recipe.

Using Marinara Sauce

In contrast, marinara sauce tends to be thinner than both pizza sauce and tomato puree. When substituting with marinara, you might need to adjust cooking times or add extra thickening agents like cornstarch or flour if necessary.

Considering the texture and savor of your dish, searching for an alternative to tomato puree is essential. Ketchup may be accessible, but other condiments could prove more suitable depending on the recipe.

4. Ketchup

As a widely available pantry staple, ketchup can serve as a suitable substitute for tomato puree in certain recipes. Ketchup, derived from tomatoes, has some resemblances in terms of taste to tomato puree. However, there are differences to consider when using this alternative.

• Texture: Ketchup has a smoother and thinner consistency compared to tomato puree. This may affect the final texture of dishes that require thicker sauces, like pasta dishes.
• Sweetness: Ketchup contains added sugar, which makes it sweeter than tomato puree. You may need to adjust other ingredients or seasoning accordingly to balance out the sweetness.
• Vinegar content: The presence of vinegar in ketchup gives it a tangy taste that is not present in tomato purees. Depending on your recipe's requirements, you might want to compensate by adding extra spices or herbs.

To use ketchup as a substitute for tomato puree, simply measure an equal amount and add it directly to your recipe while keeping these factors in mind. However, if you're looking for a more intense flavor profile, you may want to consider other tomato products such as tomato paste, canned tomatoes, or tomato sauce.

Tomato paste is a good tomato puree substitute as it has a thicker consistency and a more concentrated flavor. You can dilute it with water to achieve the desired consistency.

Canned tomatoes, pureed tomatoes, and diced tomatoes are also excellent substitutes for tomato puree. Strained canned tomatoes or strained tomatoes can be used for a smoother texture.

Related: Best Tomato Sauce Substitutes You Probably Already Have at Home

Non-Tomato Based Tomato Puree Alternatives

1. Pumpkin or Squash Puree

When seeking a unique substitute for tomato puree, consider using pumpkin or squash puree. These alternatives offer a different flavor profile while still providing the desired consistency.

Use in place of tomato puree in soups and sauces for a slightly sweeter taste with similar thickness.

Best for: Pumpkin or squash puree's smooth texture and mild sweetness make it a creative substitute for tomato puree in recipes like soups, stews, or pasta sauces, adding depth and richness.

2. Vegemite

For recipes that call for heavier ingredients like stews and casseroles, Vegemite can be an excellent choice. Its thick texture allows it to absorb other spices well, ensuring your dish remains flavorful.

Add sparingly to dishes requiring more depth of flavor; adjust seasoning as needed to suit individual preferences.

Best for: Vegemite's savory umami flavor makes it a unique substitute for tomato puree in recipes like stews, gravies, or meat marinades, adding depth and richness to dishes.

3. Fish Sauce & Worcestershire Sauce

Made from fermented fish and salt, fish sauce is a pungent liquid that adds depth and umami to various recipes. Use it sparingly, as its flavor can be quite strong.

On the other hand, Worcestershire sauce is a blend of vinegar, molasses, sugar, anchovies, tamarind extract, garlic, and other spices that create this tangy condiment which enhances savory dishes with its unique taste profile.

Start by adding a small amount (¼ teaspoon) of the alternative sauces and gradually increase until you get your desired flavor. Keep in mind that both sauces have their distinct characteristics, so experiment cautiously when substituting them into your recipe.

Best for: Fish sauce and Worcestershire sauce offer a savory and umami-rich substitute for tomato puree in recipes like marinades, stir-fries, or Asian-inspired dishes, enhancing flavor with depth and complexity.

4. Bell Peppers & Romesco

For a unique and flavorful twist, consider using red, yellow, or orange bell peppers as a base ingredient for your tomato puree substitute. These vibrant vegetables offer a natural sweetness that can complement many dishes while adding an extra layer of depth to the flavor profile.

Another option is to prepare Romesco, a traditional Spanish sauce made from roasted red peppers and almonds. This versatile sauce pairs well with various recipes such as pasta dishes, grilled meats, and seafood.

Best for: Bell peppers and romesco sauce provide a flavorful substitute for tomato puree in recipes like pasta sauces or dips, offering a sweet and smoky taste with a rich, creamy texture.

FAQs in Relation to Substitute for Tomato Puree

Don't Let a Lack of Tomato Puree Hold You Back

Finding the perfect substitute for tomato puree is now simpler than ever. With numerous alternatives, such as canned tomatoes or even non-tomato options like pumpkin puree, you can confidently adapt recipes to suit your taste and dietary needs.

By experimenting with these substitutes, you'll discover new flavor combinations and create unforgettable dishes. Whether it's due to allergies, preferences, or simply running out of tomato puree, never let a missing ingredient stand in the way of your culinary creativity.

If you're looking for more delicious recipes and cooking tips like these substitutes for tomato puree, then check out Also The Crumbs, Please.

Recipe