Cacio e Pepe | The Mediterranean Dish (2024)

Cacio e pepe is a deceptively simple recipe to make. This classic Italian pasta dish requires only three ingredients — pasta, freshly ground pepper, and real pecorino Romano cheese.

Food Stories

What is Cacio e Pepe?

What is in Cacio e Pepe?

You only need a few ingredients to make this cacio e pepe recipe, and if you’re like me, you already have them in your pantry.

• Pecorino Romano cheese: This aged sheep’s milk cheese has a pale hue, black rind, and a dry, crumbly texture that makes it good for grating. These days, pecorino romano is available at most well-stocked supermarkets. You’ll need about 2 1/2 cups finely grated Pecorino Romano for this recipe. Avoid the temptation of buying pre-shredded cheese. It’s too thick and won’t melt quickly enough to create the creamy sauce you’re after. I recommend using a microplane and grating it yourself so it’s light and fluffy.

• Black pepper: To get the most flavor, start with whole black peppercorns. Grind them yourself, either with a mortar and pestle or a spice grinder.

• Pasta: You’ll need a pound of boxed or packaged pasta for this recipe, enough to serve 4 to 6. Spaghetti is the traditional pasta for cacio e pepe, but even Roman establishments now use popular shapes such as rigatoni, bucatini, and thick, square-cut noodles called tonnarelli. Use a good quality brand that cooks evenly and retains its al dente bite.

• Pasta water: The salted water in which you boil your pasta is a key ingredient in this recipe. The boiling hot, starchy water helps to melt the pecorino cheese, forming a creamy, emulsified sauce.

How to Make Cacio e Pepe

Technique is everything with cacio e pepe. Making a creamy sauce that coats the noodles takes a bit of elbow grease and vigorous stirring, but once you’ve done it a couple of times it becomes easy.

• Put a pot of water on to boil. Fill the pot with just enough water to submerge the pasta. Use a little less water than you normally would so the water will be extra starchy as the pasta cooks. This will help in making a creamy sauce. When the water comes to a boil, add salt. Adding salt to pasta water helps to flavor the pasta. But remember that pecorino cheese is also very salty, so go easy when you salt the water. Boil the pasta, whether spaghetti or another shape, according to the package instructions, until al dente. It should be cooked through but firm to the bite.

• Grate the pecorino cheese. While the pasta boils, use a microplane or the small ‘star’ holes of a box grater to finely grate 4 ounces Pecorino Romano cheese. You’ll need about 3 very loosely filled cups. I use a microplane, as it produces a light, fluffy grated cheese that melts easily in the hot pasta water.

• Toast and grind the pepper. Place 1 tablespoon whole peppercorns in a small non-stick skillet and set it on medium-high heat. Toast the peppercorns, shaking the pan often, for 2 to 3 minutes, just until they release their fragrance. Let the peppercorns cool slightly, then pour them into a spice grinder or a mortar. Grind or pound the peppercorns until coarsely ground. The coarsely ground pepper adds both flavor and texture to cacio e pepe.

• Drain the pasta. Set a colander in the sink, with a heat-proof 2-cup measuring cup nearby. When the pasta is al dente, drain it in the colander set over a bowl. Reserve about 1 1/2 cups of the boiling water in the measuring cup. Return the pasta to the pot and pour in about 1/3 cup of the water. Return the pasta to the stove but don’t turn on the heat.

• Dress and serve the pasta. Sprinkle 2 teaspoons of pepper and a handful of pecorino into the pot followed by another splash of hot pasta water and immediately begin stirring as vigorously as you can to mix the cheese with the noodles and water. Add another splash of water and another handful of cheese and stir, stir, stir to create a creamy sauce. Elbow grease is the key here to prevent the cheese from clumping. Add one more, small handful of cheese—reserve a little for garnish—and a final splash of hot water. Stir until everything is nicely combined and the noodles are well coated. Transfer the pasta to bowls, garnish each serving with a sprinkle of pepper and pecorino cheese and serve immediately, while still hot.

Tips and Tricks

• Grate the pecorino as finely as possible. A microplane is the best tool for this job. The grated cheese should be light and airy, not densely packed.

• Use more pepper than you think you should. Most of us use pepper in small quantities when we cook, almost as an afterthought. But pepper is central to cacio e pepe so it needs to shine. Use at least 2 teaspoons and toast before grinding to bring out the pepper’s spicy and fruity notes. Pounding the peppercorns in a mortar will give you a mix of coarsely and finely ground pepper, an ideal combination in my opinion. Whatever you do, don’t use ground pepper from a shaker or canister, as it won’t be nearly as fragrant or potent.

• Don’t dawdle. Cacio e pepe must be eaten hot. No matter how creamy you manage to get your sauce, it will stiffen as it cools. So: Mix, serve, enjoy!

• Find a mixing method that works for you. My preferred method to mix cheese, pasta water, and noodles together in the pasta pot and stir as if my life depends on it. But some cooks prefer to make a paste of cheese and pasta water and then mix everything together in a large bowl. Here’s how to do it: Combine 2/3 of the grated pecorino with the pepper and enough hot pasta water to create a paste. Whisk to work out any lumps, adding more water to help melt and dissolve the cheese. Using a pasta server or tongs, transfer the noodles from the pot straight to the bowl and stir vigorously to coat the noodles. Add more pasta water from the pot as needed to make a creamy sauce. While I have tried this method, I’ve found it to be extra messy, as bits of cheese and drops of sauce tend to fly out of the bowl. Give both methods a try and see which works best for you.

What to Serve with Cacio e Pepe

Leftovers

Leftover cacio e pepe makes an excellent spaghetti frittata: Mix the leftover pasta with beaten eggs and cook the mixture in an oiled cast iron skillet until browned on the bottom; then pass it under the broiler for a couple of minutes to finish cooking and brown the top.

More Pastabilities!