Supermarket sourdough is often sourfaux – here’s how to make the real thing (2024)

After decades of filling up on flavourless crap, Britain seems to be regaining its taste for proper bread. The biggest beneficiary is chewy, tangy sourdough, which makes a treat of the simplest sarnie. Tesco – hardly a foodie destination – now sells 100,000 loaves of it every week, with sales up 40% in a year.

Sourdough is the oldest leavened bread; the bubbles that make it rise are created not by the commercial yeast used in the vast majority of bread baking, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, but by naturally occurring yeasts found on flour and in the air. It was probably invented when one of our ancestors left some wet flour in the sun and noticed it starting to froth.

Not only does sourdough taste great; there is some evidence it can be tolerated by many people who have trouble digesting bread produced with commercial yeast.

But not all sourdough is created equal. While purists will tell you it should be made from just flour, water, salt and a “starter” that is in turn made from flour, water and the above-mentioned naturally occuring yeasts, Which? has found that most supermarket sourdoughs are adulterated with anything from yoghurt and vinegar to – and this is the real killer – commercial yeast. Those ingredients aren’t bad for you, unless you have a specific intolerance – but to describe bread made with commercial yeast as sourdough is, not to put too fine a point on it, complete and utter bollocks.

How can you avoid this sourfaux? You can check the ingredients, of course – if the supermarket lists them – or switch to an artisan bakery (and ask about the ingredients there, too). Or, you could just make it yourself. It has a reputation for being tricky, labour-intensive and horribly slow, but again, this is a misconception. All you are doing is replacing one quick-acting, predictable ingredient with another that is less consistent and lazier. Everything takes longer, but on the plus side, that gives the dough more time to build flavour.

If you have ever made bread by hand (loading up a machine doesn’t count), you can make sourdough. You will need to be in the general vicinity of the kitchen for about half a day, but for most of that you will simply be waiting for dough to rise. The breadmaking itself won’t get in the way of any dusting, childcare or drinking in front of the telly that you may have planned. Here is a simple recipe, with instructions on how to make a starter.

Supermarket sourdough is often sourfaux – here’s how to make the real thing (2024)

FAQs

Is grocery store sourdough fake? ›

Despite the fact that traditional sourdough ingredients are flour, water, and salt, many store-bought versions include added yeast, ascorbic acid, vinegar, and oil. So, although many grocery stores may carry bread labeled “sourdough”, more often than not they are in fact fake sourdough.

Is supermarket sourdough real sourdough? ›

It may have been fermented for longer than standard bread but that does not make it a sourdough. A sourdough is a bread leavened with a sourdough culture, which comprises wild yeasts and lactobacilli bacteria.

Why is store-bought sourdough so sour? ›

One consequence of the common belief that sourdough should be sour is that commercial sourdough is too sour. Sadly, most commercial sourdoughs aren't actually sourdough breads. They are yeasted breads that have had acetic acid, malic acid, and/or fumaric acid added to them.

Is Aldi's sourdough bread real sourdough? ›

ALDI has “real” sourdough bread (no yeast). Being somewhat gluten intolerant, I have found “real” sourdough works for me, no bloating etc.

How to tell if sourdough is real? ›

Always read the label.

Genuine sourdough bread is NOT made using additives, baker's yeast (usually listed simply as yeast) or chemical raising agents (eg baking powder). If there isn't a label (or you just fancy a chat) then... Ask the baker / salesperson for a copy of the ingredients list.

Is grocery store sourdough healthy? ›

Interestingly enough, sourdough bread does boast quite a few health benefits when compared to many conventional bread options found at the grocery store, especially from a digestive health standpoint. After all, sourdough bread is anti-inflammatory, which has several health benefits.

Is Costco sourdough bread real sourdough? ›

Despite the omission of a live starter culture, and the use of baker's yeast and an additive, Costco marketed the product using the word sourdough.

Which is the healthiest sourdough bread? ›

“The whole-grain sourdoughs have more fiber, protein and micronutrients, making them more filling and healthier for you overall,” says Natalie Rizzo, registered dietitian and nutrition editor at TODAY.com.

Who makes Aldi sourdough bread? ›

Meet the Supplier - Geary's Bakeries

This 4th generation, family-owned bakery has been supplying Aldi stores since 2005 with award-winning British breads that our customers love.

Why does my sourdough not taste like sourdough? ›

Still, there are three specific factors that can really affect your bread's flavor: The health of your starter. The level of the bread dough's organic acids. The complex relationships over time between levain, dough, fermentation, and proofing.

Why does sourdough go bad? ›

Yes, sourdough bread can go mouldy if stored in a plastic bag or container in hot and humid conditions with no airflow, especially if it hasn't been allowed to cool properly after baking. While this may not happen immediately you may notice mould growth around day three if the conditions aren't favourable.

What is the secret behind the sour of sourdough bread? ›

A sourdough starter is made up of wild yeast and bacteria working together. The bacteria is where the sour flavor is coming from! Lactic Acid Bacteria are most active in the mid 80-90 degrees F, but that speeds up the wild yeast which prefer a more mild temperature of mid 70s F.

Is Panera sourdough real sourdough? ›

Panera's sourdough loaf is a far cry from classic

The Panera website lists the full ingredients of its "Classic Sourdough Loaf," and they're a far cry from true sourdough's minimal lineup of flour, water, salt, and live culture. In addition to wheat and malted barley flour, the sourdough starter contains folic acid.

Is supermarket sourdough upf? ›

Not all bread counts as UPF. A loaf containing just flour, salt, and yeast is simply “processed” and processed food isn't a problem. Many of the expensive sourdoughs fit into this category.

Does Pepperidge Farm make sourdough bread? ›

Our dedication to quality shows in the care we put into every detail. Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Sourdough Bread stays true to the classic recipe you know and love: A delicious, versatile sourdough bread baked with quality ingredients and a touch of sweetness.

How do grocery stores make sourdough? ›

Many store-bought “sourdough” breads use just a small amount of sourdough starter and throw that and other flavors in there to give the bread a sourdough taste — while the action of rising the bread is done with commercial yeast.

Is Trader Joe's sourdough fermented? ›

As a result, the Trader Joe's item attracts fans from across the internet. Its charm is in its subtlety. Unlike some highly fermented options, this grocery store version is mild in flavor and enjoyably wheaty. And, because sourdough is made via fermentation, it might be easier to digest (per Medical News Today).

Top Articles
What is Butter Pecan?
17 Secrets Olive Garden Doesn’t Want You to Know
Ilovepersuasian
Burkes Outlet Credit Card Sign In
Nycers Pay Schedule
Levidia 2019
Blowupgirls Thread
Bg3 Fake Portrait Of A Noble Before His Death
Wow Rock Wall Locked
Missed Connections Dayton Ohio
gameplay:shiny_pokemon_and_luck [PokéRogue Wiki]
Kimpton Hotels In Charleston Sc
Integrations | Information Technology
Mhgu Bealite Ore
Mynorthwoodtech
Fungal Symbiote Terraria
Mexi Unblocked Games
5162635626
Connection | Scoop.it
How To Pause Tamagotchi Gen 2
Craigsliststcloud
4201 Crossroads Wy, Rancho Cordova, CA 95742 - MLS 224103058 - Coldwell Banker
Freehold Township Patch
Andhrajyoti
Match The Criminal To The Weapon
Doculivery Trinity Health
Age Of Attila's Rain Crossword
Chevalier Showtimes Near Island 16 Cinema De Lux
Ticket To Paradise Showtimes Near Laemmle Newhall
Arsenal’s Auston Trusty: Inspired by Ronaldinho, World Cup dreams and Birmingham loan
Lenscrafters Westchester Mall
Studentvue Paramount
Of Course! havo/vwo bovenbouw
Rg353M Vs Rg351Mp
Actors In Sleep Number Commercial
Ts Massage San Jose Ca
Circuit Court Peoria Il
Personapay/Glens Falls Hospital
Who To Start for Fantasy Football Friday Night Football: Week 1 (2024)
Minute Clinic Schedule 360
Erica Mena Net Worth Forbes
Neo Geo Bios Raspberry Pi 3
Roman Numerals Chart, Translation Tips & History
Transactions on Computational Social Systems - IEEE SMC
Salon5 – Europa, was geht? – Podcast
Yahoo Sports Pga Leaderboard
Buzzn Dispensary
Intervallfasten 5/2: Einfache Anfänger-Anleitung zur 5:2-Diät
Iemand ervaring met FC-MOTO??
South Florida residents must earn more than $100,000 to avoid being 'rent burdened'
Truck Trader Pennsylvania
Mecklenburg Warrant Search
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated:

Views: 6539

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.